AI Assistants vs Virtual Executive Assistants

In the constantly changing landscape of digital assistance, we've seen how AI assistants and executive virtual assistants stand out. The remarkable progress of the AI assistant has raised concerns about its potential to replace the executive virtual assistant. However, in our opinion, AI can never replace humans.

Both AI assistants and executive virtual assistants are useful for businesses. Although AI assistants have impressive features, there are still specific traits that make executive virtual assistants unmatched. Knowing the differences between the two helps you use them effectively.

In this article, we will talk about the differences between AI assistants and executive assistants and help you determine which is more ideal for your business.

‍

What Is an AI Assistant?

An AI assistant is a tool or software that can perform specialised tasks and give information based on pre-programmed algorithms. It is capable of understanding commands and carrying out tasks for its users. They usually perform tasks such as organising meetings, managing emails, giving reminders, and answering general questions based on the features they have.

‍

What Is a Virtual Executive Assistant?

Virtual executive assistants are real humans who provide support to executives and business owners with their needs. They usually excel in administrative tasks, managing projects and time, providing customer support, and assisting with routine tasks. Their support allows their clients to have more time to concentrate on business growth and strategies.  

‍

AI Assistant vs Virtual Executive Assistant: What’s the Difference Between the Two?

Adaptability

AI Assistants. AI assistants are preprogrammed to perform specific tasks. Fyxer.AI is a good example. It is an AI assistant specifically designed to help manage your inbox. As such, it can help organise your emails into different categories, schedule appointments that come through your email, and even draft responses.  

However, at the end of the day, it won’t be able to send emails on your behalf, manage your schedule according to your priorities, and perform other tasks that will involve human decision-making and intuition.

Virtual Executive Assistants. Virtual executive assistants, especially the most experienced ones, are used to dealing with different situations. They can quickly adjust to new environments, tasks, and other challenges where you will need their support. They can assess problems, come up with ideas, and implement tailored solutions as needed.

Winner: Virtual Executive Assistants

AI assistants only rely on set programmes, so they may not completely tailor what you need, whereas virtual executive assistants can offer specialised support based on your demands. So, in terms of adaptability, the executive virtual assistant clearly wins.

If you work with a virtual assistant agency, such as HireHarbour, your virtual executive assistant can get more training based on your preferences. Additionally, we provide our executive assistants with training on how to utilise AI tools to ensure that our clients can make full use of them.

‍

Empathy

AI Assistants. Although AI assistants are quick and provide accurate answers, they may lack emotional understanding because of their pre-programmed responses, which makes them less appropriate for tasks requiring human connection or empathy.

For instance, an AI assistant that is programmed to provide customer support to the user suddenly receives complaints because they're having problems with the product they bought for a special occasion, such as a defective item.  

If the buyer informs an AI assistant that they are upset and disappointed, the AI may respond with a standard apology and an operational solution, such as issuing a refund and offering a replacement, without recognizing how sentimental the matter is to the buyer. This could make the conversation feel cold and unimportant.  

Virtual Executive Assistants They are good at comprehending and reacting to complex emotions and scenarios because they bring a human touch and empathetic understanding to conversations.

For instance, an executive is dealing with personal issues, such as a family member's illness, while still managing an important company project. A virtual executive assistant may sense the executive's stress and emotional strain and show genuine support.  

They will offer great assistance, such as adjusting the executive's schedule to provide more flexibility, addressing conversations with empathy, and even recommending breaks or leave to deal with their personal problems. This empathetic approach not only assists the executive in managing their emotions but also guarantees that their well-being and work commitments are properly balanced.

Winner: Virtual Executive Assistants

In terms of empathy, the executive virtual assistant is still the winner. AI assistants don't exhibit the same level of empathy as executive virtual assistants.

‍

Communication Skills

AI Assistants. Despite AI assistants being quick and efficient at responding and providing information, they cannot engage in complex conversations since it often results in less accurate or relevant responses.

Virtual Executive Assistants. Virtual executive assistants are good communicators because they actively listen and can adapt their tone, language, and humour, which makes them comfortable to talk to. They can also provide personalised guidance and insights regarding the business problem you are facing.

However, not all virtual executive assistants are great communicators, and this is where agencies like HireHarbour step in, which implements a rigorous selection process and provides training on communication skills.

Winner: Virtual Executive Assistants

When it comes to communication skills, executive virtual assistants remain the winners. AI assistant interactions rely on scripted responses and programming, while executive virtual assistants can actively listen to your needs and give ideas and suggestions.

‍

Availability

AI Assistants. The AI assistants can provide around-the-clock support and instant responses to queries and commands without the limitations of regular working hours. They are always ready to function day and night, ensuring continuous access for users.

Virtual Executive Assistants. The executive virtual assistants only work during set working hours. Within those hours, they provide dedicated, high-level support. This means that they can provide more comprehensive and personalised help. However, it's not possible for them to work continuously all day, as humans require sleep to fully function.

Winner: AI Assistants

Clearly, the winner here are the AI assistants. Executive virtual assistants have scheduled work hours and human limitations, but AI assistants can operate 24/7.

‍

Security and Confidentiality

AI Assistants. The AI assistants pose some cybersecurity risks, such as collecting and exposing your data to unidentified third parties. Due to the amount of private data, they could handle, some features of AI assistants like managing administrative tasks, organising appointments, and providing research support may come with a built-in cyber security risk.

Virtual Executive Assistants. The virtual executive assistants always prioritise security and confidentiality by following the privacy protocols that their clients give them. Aside from that, they sign non-disclosure agreements (“NDAs”) that formally bind them to keep private information safe.

Winner: Virtual Executive Assistants

Regarding security and confidentiality, executive virtual assistants are again the winners. AI assistant interactions rely on set programmes, so giving them your personal information would be risky. In contrast, executive virtual assistants can maintain a level of confidentiality that automated systems cannot match.

‍

Premium AI Assistant Services

If you'd rather have an AI assistant than a virtual executive assistant, here are some services you might want to consider.

Lindy

Lindy is an AI assistant developed to assist high performers with their daily responsibilities and serve as an executive assistant. Lindy can be transformed into an automated executive assistant to manage email and travel arrangements, a scribe to transcribe medical notes, a chatbot to automate customer service, or a customized solution for your business function and teams.

Note: In the meantime, they are currently under development and have not yet been launched. However, if you want to use it as soon as it becomes available, you can join their waitlist.

‍

Fyxer AI

Fyxer AI specialises in email management. It helps organise inboxes and draft emails in Gmail or Outlook. It will help teams, starters, and enterprises respond to emails faster than they were able to before. All it takes to get started is to connect the Gmail or Outlook account to it, and it is good to go.

‍

AI Assistant  

AI Assistant is designed to help people be more productive with things like research, planning, automating tasks, making documents, analysing data, communicating, and more. It helps them save time, increase productivity, and make your work and personal lives easier. Its features are useful for teams, individuals, and businesses.

‍

Premium Executive Virtual Assistant Providers

Though there are a lot of executive virtual assistant services to choose from, these three are the best ones you should consider.

HireHarbour  

HireHarbour is a premium fractional virtual assistance business that helps executives, entrepreneurs, business owners, high performers, and solopreneurs with their virtual assistant needs.  

What sets us apart from our competitors is that our executive virtual assistants undergo a thorough 3-week training program before collaborating with clients, have on-going training to continuously upskill, and offer fractional recruitment.  

In addition, our fractional model lets you fully tailor your assistant's schedule based on your specific requirements and preferences, without the limits of a part-timer or the commitment of a full-timer.

‍

Boldly

Boldly is focused on providing skilled and experienced executive virtual assistants if that's what you're looking for. They have professionals on their team who have 10-15 years of experience. Additionally, their executive assistants are based in the US, so their service may be a little more expensive compared to other EVA services.  

‍

Athena  

Athena excels at delegating. Over the years, they have honed a huge collection of resources, with a specific focus on task delegation. This makes them perfect for startup founders who are still learning how to delegate tasks effectively.

Want to compare the three premium executive assistant providers? Check out our article, The Top 3 Executive Virtual Assistant Providers, for a more detailed breakdown of their differences.

‍

Factors to Consider When Choosing the Right Assistant for You

Capability

When choosing your assistant, you need to understand their strengths and their limits. Ensure that the assistant you want has the necessary expertise or features that will be useful for the tasks that you need assistance with.

‍

Budget

Determine whether your budget can afford the subscriptions, memberships, or rates of the services you need. If the pricing exceeds your budget, consider exploring alternative options. Find one that you can afford, and check if the price aligns with their services and features.  

However, most AI assistant subscriptions are under 100 USD per month, whereas executive virtual assistant services are generally 1000–3000 USD per month. While it may not be suitable for everyone, for those who have the budget, it's a viable option if you really want to level up.

‍

Security and Privacy

Having your sensitive information leaked is the last thing you want to happen. That is why you must be cautious when recruiting an executive virtual assistant or using AI assistant. This terrifying incident could be avoided with the right practices for hiring EVAs and using AIs.

If you're going to hire executive virtual assistants, make sure to have them sign non-disclosure agreements. And if you're going to use AI assistants, review whether the data privacy policies are acceptable and refrain from disclosing extremely private information.

‍